Superwoman Vs Wonderwoman

Lagunya Mulan wonder woman lagi happening banget yah sekarang. gw nilai begitu soalnya mulai dari kontes nyanyi ibu-anak di stasiun TV swasta (adek gw demen bgt), pengamen di bus merak-jakarta, pengamen di pinggir jalan, bahkan ampe ada versi pop-dut nya (sayang ga sempet gw record).
Pendapat gw pribadi tentang lagu ini (bukan Mulannya loh..) hampir sama dengan kebanyakan lagu Indonesia sekarang, 'DANGKAL' banget..!!!
easy listening?, YES!!
melody/rhytm ?OK lah..
Meaningful? NO..!!!.
kenapa gw bilang ga meaningful, liat aja lirik lagunya shallow, lagunya ga bercerita dengan 'manis' , malah cenderung (sorry) murahan..

WONDER WOMEN - Mulan J

kamu tipu aku lagi
mungkin sudah 1000 kali
tak tau kapan akan berakhir
sgala penyiksaan ini

kamu tampar aku lagi
dengan penyakit lamamu
semakin lama aku pun bisa
menjadi benar-benar gila

[reff]
aku bukan wonder womanmu
yang bisa terus menahan
rasa sakit karna mencintaimu
hatiku kini bukanlah hati
yang tercipta dari besi dan baja
hatiku kini bisa remuk dan hancur

kamu paksa aku
menerima cintamu lagi
dengan segala tingkah lakumu
yang membuatku bingung

kamu tahan aku
dengan memikatku lagi
kau pikir aku akan mencair
dengan rayuanmu

Coba deh klo kita bandingkan dengan lagu yang berteman wanita super lainnya, seperti Superwoman kepunyaan Karyn White yang pernah direcycle oleh Jaclyn Victor (Malaysian Idol). Apalagi klo kita bandingkan dengan Superwoman, Alicia Keys Version, waduh nge-jomplang banget..!!!

Superwoman - Karyn White / Jaclyn Victor
Early in the morning I put breakfast at your table,
and make sure that your coffee has its sugar and cream...
Your eggs are overeasy, your toast done litely,
all that's missing is your morning kiss that used to greet me...
Now you say the juice is sour, it used to be so sweet,
and I can't help but to wonder if you're talking about me...
We don't talk the way we used to talk, it's hurting so deep,
I've got my pride, I will not cry, but it's making me weak...

I'm not your superwoman...
I'm not the kind of girl that you can let down,
and think that everything is okay...
Boy I am only human...
This girl needs more than occasional hugs
as a token of love from you to me...

I fought my way through the rush hour trying to make it home just for you...
I want to make sure that your dinner will be waiting for you...
But when you get there, you just tell me you're not hungry at all,
you said you'd rather read the paper and you don't want to talk...
You like to think that I'm just crazy when I say that you've changed,
I'm convinced I know the problem, you don't love me the same...
You're just going through the motions and you're not being fair,
I've got my pride, I will not cry, still I can't help but care!!!

REFF

Oooh, baby!!!
Look into the corners of your mind,
I'll always be there for you through good and bad times,
but I can't be the superwoman that you want me to be!!
I'll give my everlasting love if you'll return love to me!!
I'm not your superwoman!!!!

Reff

Oh!!! If you feel it in your heart and you understand me,
stop right where you are, everybody sing along with me!
(hoo, hoo, hoo, hoo, hoo, hoo, hoo...)
I'm the kind of girl that can treat you so sweet,
but you got to realize that you got to be sweeter to me!!!
I need love, I need just your love, I'm not your superwoman...

Superwoman - Alicia Keys
Everywhere I'm turning
Nothing seems complete
I stand up and I'm searching
For the better part of me
I hang my head from sorrow
Slave to humanity
I wear it on my shoulders
Gotta find the strength in me

Cause I am a Superwoman
Yes I am
Yes she is
Even when I'm a mess
I still put on a vest
With an S on my chest
Oh yes
I'm a Superwoman (Reff)

For all the mothers fighting
For better days to come
And all my women, all my women sitting here trying
To come home before the sun
And all my sisters
Coming together
Say yes I will
Yes I can

Reff

When I'm breaking down
And I can't be found
And I start to get weak
Cause no one knows
Me underneath these clothes
But I can fly
We can fly, Oooohh (Back To reff)

Karyn White, Alicia Keys, Jaclyn Victor VS Mulan Jameela (skala 0-5)

Kualitas vokal : 5 - 2 (World Class VS Penyanyi kafe yang tiba-tiba nge-TOP)
Lirik : 5 - 0
Melodi : 5 - 2
Star Attitude : 5 - 0

sorry, klo ada fans mulan yang ngerasa kesentil ma tulisan gw tapi coba deh lo semua dengerin penyanyi-penyanyi yang gw sebutin diatas, waduh..beda level euy..they are far above mulan jamilah/kwok or mulan whatever lah..dan mereka semua ngebuktiin ga perlu jadi makhluk tuhan yang paling seksi untuk menjadi Super/Wonder woman buktiin aja gw bener atau salah..